A gift basket is the safer choice, and a kind one. It goes round the office, it is gone by Friday, and it is remembered about as long.
The gift that is remembered is the one that goes to work. A pen that signs every letter that leaves the office. A briefcase carried into court on the morning of trial. A planner opened before the first call of the day. A lawyer reaches for these every working day, and now and then, picking one up, thinks of the person who gave it.
Everything here was chosen by a lawyer who practiced for twenty-six years and knows which objects earn their place on the desk and which do not. Nothing is engraved with a joke. Nothing announces itself. Each piece does its job, and keeps doing it.
What to Give a Lawyer, and What a Lawyer May Accept, Field Guide No. 12, takes each occasion from law school to the close of a career, and sets out what a client, a colleague or a friend may give, with the rules cited.
For the law student, a padfolio and a first good pen. For the graduate, the bag for the first job; for the new bar passer, the pen. At the swearing-in, a fountain pen for the career and a case for the cards. For the new associate, a padfolio for the conference room; for the lawyer opening a practice, a desk that is finally the lawyer's own. For a first win, the pen or the book that keeps the day; for a substantial verdict or closing, the pen for the next signing table. For the new partner, a briefcase worth the title; for a sabbatical, leather for the travel; for the twenty-fifth year, a pen or a briefcase sized to the years. At the close of a career, a journal and travel leather for retirement, a desk set for the lawyer going of counsel, and something for the new office of a lawyer entering public service.
For a judge taking the bench, the rules on who may give what are set out in What to Give a Judge, and Who May Give It; the gifts themselves are in Gifts for Judges. If the choice is hard, start with the pen: every lawyer signs something every day. Our gift guide walks through every occasion, with four pieces for each.